| Champion | Date Won | Title Reign | Notes |
|---|
| Cowgirls From Hell | 04-24-2010 | 139 days | Over Down South Georgia Boys and Hell and High Water on Night One of RPM 2 |
| Down South Georgia Boys (Jethro Hayes [4] & Bubba J) | 04-11-2010 | 13 days | Engel was removed from Second 2 None by contract and Jethro chose Bubba J as his new partner. |
| Second 2 None (Jethro Hayes [3] & Matthew Engel [2]) | 03-07-2010 | 35 days | Over Tha Impact Playaz |
| Tha Impact Playaz (Viktor Stone & Shadow Starr) | 01-09-2010 | 57 days | Over The Order of Chaos |
| The Order of Chaos (Simon Kalis & Masakazu) | 09-21-2009 | 110 days | Over Riona Langly & Emperor Ian |
| Riona Langly [2] & Emperor Ian [2] | 08-29-2009 | 23 days | Over The Pantheon in a Steel Cage Match |
| Pantheon (Hunter Sullivan [3] & The Phoenix[2]) | 08-22-2009 | 7 days | Over Riona Langly & Emperor Ian |
| Riona Langly & Emperor Ian | 08-16-2009 | 6 days | Over The Maverick Initiative |
| The Maverick Initiative (Johnny [3] and Gary Maverick) | 08-11-2009 | 5 days | Jacob Figgins is injured by the Pantheon, Johnny Maverick picks his brother Gary to hold the other tag title. |
| Chaos Theory [2] (Jacob Figgins [3] & Johnny Maverick [2]) | 07-04-2009 | 38 days | Over Krymson Dragons |
| Krymson Dragons [3] (Raizzor [5] & Chamelion [3]) | 06-27-2009 | 7 days | Over Chaos Theory |
| Chaos Theory (Jacob Figgins [2] & Johnny Maverick) | 06-14-2009 | 13 days | Over Renegade Souljahs |
| Renegade Souljahs [2] (Mark Zout [2] & Ryan Ross [2]) | 05-02-2009 | 43 days | Over G.O.D. |
| G.O.D Generation of Destruction (Hunter Sullivan [2] & Jacob Figgins) | 03-15-2009 | 48 days | Over Renegade Souljahs |
| Renegade Souljahs (Mark Zout & Ryan Ross) | 03-07-2009 | 8 days | Pinned Enika Engel in a Handicap match due to Flynn's departure |
| Jamie Flynn [3] & Enika Engel [3]l | 02-15-2009 | 20 days | Jamie Flynn turns on Kyle Stevenson and joins up with Enika Engel |
| Jamie Flynn [2] & Kyle Stevenson | 12-12-2008 | 65 days | Over Jethro Hayes & Hunter Sullivan |
| Jethro Hayes [2] & Hunter Sullivan | 12-05-2008 | 7 days | Hunter Sullivan wins tournament to hold other Tag Team Championship. |
| VACANT | 11-11-2008 | 24 days | Jamie Flynn leaves PWA |
| The Farm and Harm Express (Jamie Flynn & Jethro Hayes) | 10-17-2008 | 25 days | Over Nightmare & El Rey de Corazones |
| "Nightmare" Jonothan Wehali & El Rey de Corazones | 08-15-2008 | 63 days | Over Project-X & Psycho Sandra in the Finals of the United Forces Tournament 2008 |
| VACANT | 07-11-2008 | 35 days | Titles vacated due to double pin, belts held up for United Forces Tournament |
| Lunatic Fringe [2] (Sirus [16] & Randall Moran [2]) | 06-13-2008 | 28 days | Defeated The Deadpool for the Vacant titles |
| VACANT | 06-04-2008 | 9 days | Raizzor, new owner of PWA, stripped Razordolls of Tag Titles |
| Razordolls (Lisa Seldon & Dahlia.) | 04-18-2008 | 47 days | Over Might & Magic |
| Might & Magic [2] | 03-14-2008 | 35 days | Over Lunatic Fringe |
| Lunatic Fringe (Sirus [15] & Randall Moran) | 02-15-2008 | 28 days | Over Exit Music |
| Exit Music (Matthew Engel and Enika Engel [2]) | 02-01-2008 | 14 days | Enika and Matthew defeated Kirlia and Icetank to decide the true tag team champs |
| Kirlia Gardevoir & Enika Engel | 01-25-2008 | 7 days | Won Keys #2 & #5 in Keys to Glory event |
| VACANT | 09-30-2006 | 482 days | PWA Closes Down Once Again |
| The Brothers Grimm [12] (Sirus Moran [14] & Grifter [13]) | 06-25-2006 | 97 days | Over the Red Army Warriors |
| The Brothers Grimm [11] (Sirus Moran [13] & Grifter [12]) | 10-28-2002 | 1336 days | Over Straders Inc. to unify the PWA and W4F tag team titles. |
| The Brothers Grimm [10] (Sirus Moran [12] & Grifter [11]) | 06-08-2002 | 142 days | Over the Cereal Killas |
| Cereal Killas [3] | 05-26-2002 | 13 days | Over Prisoner & Phoenix and Collins & Anderson |
| "The Phoenix" Rob Robinson & The Prisoner | 04-28-2002 | 28 days | Over Collins & Anderson |
| VACANT | 04-14-2002 | 14 days | Thunderwolf leaves the PWA for personal reasons |
| Thunderwolf & Sirus Moran [11] | 02-04-2002 | 69 days | Over Jekyll & Hyde for the Vacant title. |
| VACANT | 01-06-2002 | 29 days | Fallen Angel leaves the PWA for personal reasons |
| Inner Fury ("Thunderwolf" Dustin Kelser & Fallen Angel) | 12-19-2001 | 18 days | Over Team Supreme |
| Team Supreme (Raizzor [4] & Sirus Moran [10]) | 11-04-2001 | 45 days | Over the Cereal Killas |
| Cereal Killas [2] | 10-20-2001 | 15 days | Over the Krymson Dragons |
| Krymson Dragons (Raizzor [3] & Chamelion [2]) | 10-13-2001 | 7 days | Over the Cereal Killas |
| Cereal Killas | 09-30-2001 | 13 days | Over The Brothers Grimm |
| The Brothers Grimm [9] (Sirus Moran [9] & Grifter [10]) | 07-29-2001 | 63 days | Over Beauty & the Brutal |
| Beauty & The Brutal | 05-02-2001 | 88 days | Over the Krymson Dragons, Cereal Killas, and Syck & Twyzted |
| Sudden Impact ("Showtime" Marcus Ambrose & Jay) | 11-26-2000 | 157 days | Over The Brothers Grimm and Chamelion & Psycho Sandra in a Triple Threat Tag Match. |
| The Brothers Grimm [7] (Sirus Moran [7] & Grifter [8]) | 10-08-2000 | 49 days | Over DEATH (Represented by Grendle and Spider) |
| DEATH (Spider & Sword [2]) | 09-13-2000 | 25 days | Over Nightmare (No partner) |
| Nightmare & Sword | 09-03-2000 | 10 days | Over The Brothers Grimm |
| The Brothers Grimm [6] (Sirus Moran [6] & Grifter [7]) | 04-30-2000 | 126 days | Over Might & Magic |
| Might & Magic | 03-22-2000 | 39 days | Over The Brothers Grimm |
| The Brothers Grimm [5] (Sirus Moran [5] & Grifter [6]) | 02-13-2000 | 38 days | Over Rage & Faith. |
| Rage & Faith [3] | 01-22-2000 | 22 days | Rage beats Messiah in a match for his half of the tag team belts. |
| Messiah & Faith [2] | 01-22-2000 | 0 days | Messiah beats Grifter in a Boiler Room Brawl to gain the other half of the belts. |
| Grifter [5] & Faith | 01-22-2000 | 0 days | Faith given Sirus' half of the tag team belts in exchange for 'Al'. |
| The Brothers Grimm [8] (Sirus Moran [8] & Grifter [9]) | 01-18-2000 | 4 days | Over Sudden Impact |
| Brothers Grimm [4] (Sirus Moran [4] & Grifter [4]) | 12-08-1999 | 41 days | Over The Creatures of the Night. |
| Creatures of the Night [2] (Monkey McDee [2] and Nightstyker [2]) | 10-31-1999 | 38 days | Over The Brothers Grimm |
| Brothers Grimm [3] (Sirus Moran [3] & Grifter [3]) | 10-09-1999 | 22 days | Over the Creatures of the Night |
| Creatures of the Night (Monkey McDee & Nightstryker) | 10-06-1999 | 3 days | Over Unknown Demons in a Lumberjack Match. |
| Unknown Demons | 08-29-1999 | 38 days | Over Rage & Fear and The Brothers Grimm |
| Rage & Fear | 08-11-1999 | 18 days | Over The Brothers Grimm |
| Brothers Grimm [2] (Sirus Moran [2] & Grifter [2]) | 07-21-1999 | 21 days | Over Mikey P & Steve Morley |
| Mikey P & Steve Morely | 07-18-1999 | 3 days | Over The Usual Suspects |
| The Usual Suspects (B Dubbs & Mr T) | 06-29-1999 | 19 days | Over the Brothers Grimm |
| The Corpse & Gareth Evans | 06-27-1999 | 2 days | Over The Brothers Grimm |
| Brothers Grimm (Sirus Moran & Grifter) | 06-08-1999 | 19 days | Over The Hellraizers |
| The Hellraizers (BBB & The Animal) | 05-30-1999 | 9 days | Over the Usual Suspects, Brothers Grimm, and the ICONS. |
| The ICONS (Southpaw & Slice) | 05-04-1999 | 26 days | Over the Deadly Combination for the vacant titles |
| VACANT | 04-29-1999 | 5 days | President Robinson wouldn't allow one man to hold the Tag Titles. |
| Raizzor | 04-27-1999 | 2 days | Over The ICONS in a handicap match (used ring name Chamelion). |
| The ICONS (PD & Cinergy) | 04-22-1999 | 5 days | Over The Usual Suspects, The Diamond Connection and Deadly Combination |
